Analysis of Terra/Luna Collapse and Fraud Liability under Polish Criminal Code in Light of MiCAR and MiFID II Amendments
PDF

Keywords

virtual asset
stablecoin
DeFi
TerraUSD
MiCAR
financial instrument
Yield Farming
Anchor Protocol
fraud

How to Cite

Behan, A. (2024). Analysis of Terra/Luna Collapse and Fraud Liability under Polish Criminal Code in Light of MiCAR and MiFID II Amendments. Forum Prawnicze, (6(80), 81–97. https://doi.org/10.32082/fp.6(80).2023.1252

Abstract

The article considers implications of algorithmic stablecoins, with a particular focus on the Terra/Luna ecosystem and their impact on the financial and regulatory landscape. It examines the collapse of Terra USD (UST) and its subsequent effects on the global cryptocurrency market. The article delves into the mechanics of UST's pegging mechanism, which relied on complex algorithmic adjustments without fiat collateral, leading to its dramatic devaluation. The study highlights the regulatory challenges posed by decentralized financial systems and algorithmic stablecoins, emphasizing the difficulties in legally addressing the actions of creators within a system perceived as a financial pyramid. It underscores the need for cleaner regulatory frameworks, not only in Polish legislation but also under the MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets) regulation in the EU, along with similar legislative efforts globally. By analyzing the systemic risks and vulnerabilities exposed by the Terra/ Luna collapse, the article advocates for balanced regulatory approach that ensures investor protection while fostering innovation.

https://doi.org/10.32082/fp.6(80).2023.1252
PDF

References

[@4484], Tweet (2022), https://twitter.com/4484/status/ 1524006086147252227 (access: 24.07.2024).

A. Behan, Waluty wirtualne jako przedmiot przestępstwa (Krakowski Instytut Prawa Karnego Fundacja, 2022). Algod [@AlgodTrading], Tweet, (2022, March 13), https://twitter. com/AlgodTrading/status/1503103705939423234 (access: 02.06.2024).

Anonymous, Anchor documentation site (2022), https://perma. cc/9E6D-ELEG (access: 02.06.2024).

Anonymous, Bonded Assets (bAssets) (2022, July 9), https://perma. cc/8NFN-J3N8 (access: 02.06.2024).

Anonymous, Charts (2022, July 10), https://perma.cc/UL3YEHU5 (access: 02.06.2024).

Anonymous, Exchange migration guide (2022, July 11), https:// perma.cc/BRC9-FHTU (access: 02.06.2024).

Anonymous, What Is Binance DeFi Staking and How to Use It (2020, August 19), https://perma.cc/YSG8-9CJK (access: 02.06.2024).

Anonymous, Yield Farming in DeFi: A Complete Guide, (2022, July 11), https://perma.cc/J5GC-666C (access: 02.06.2024).

Barthere, Aurelie, Baraki, Veili, Li Khoo, Yong, Grushyn, Philip, Ti Lim, Xin, Ho, Joshua, On-Chain Forensics: Demystifying TerraUSD Depeg (2022), https://perma.cc/2GKL-U6BG (access: 02.06.2024).

Chybiński, Olgierd, Gutekunst, Włodzimierz, Świda, Witold, Prawo karne: część szczególna, zagadnienia wybrane, (PWN, 1965). Clements, Ryan, "Built to Fail: The Inherent Fragility of Algorithmic Stablecoins", Wake Forest Law Review Online 131 (2021), http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3952045 (access: 02.06.2024).

Dąbrowska-Kardas, Małgorzata, Kardas, Piotr, "Art. 286", in Kodeks karny. Część szczególna, vol. 3, Włodzimierz Wróbel, Andrzej Zoll eds. (Wolter Kluwer, 2022), 289-359.

ECB Crypto-assets Task Force, "Stablecoins: Implications for monetary policy, financial stability, market infrastructure and payments, and banking supervision in the euro area", Occasional Paper Series 247 (2020), https://perma.cc/QAF3- BNXM (access: 02.06.2024).

Elizabeth II, Queen of the United Kingdom, and the other Commonwealth realms, Speech (2022), https://www.gov.uk/government/ speeches/queens-speech-2022 (access: 02.06.2024).

Encila, Jet, Three Arrows Capital Founders Nowhere to Be Found, Liquidators Say (2022), https://perma.cc/HVP6-AJ22 (access: 02.06.2024).

Everington, Keoni, Taiwanese man commits suicide after losing nearly NT$60 million from Luna crypto crash (2022), https://perma.cc/KF4V-ELXZ (access: 02.06.2024).

Godbole, Omkar, Anchor Protocol Reserves Slide as Money Market"s Founder Talks Down Concerns (2022), https://perma.cc/ DC55-MPQQ (access: 02.06.2024).

Górniok, Oktawia, Pleńska, Danuta, "Przestępstwa przeciwko mieniu", in System prawa karnego. O przestępstwach w szczególności, Igor Andrejew, Leszek Kubicki, Jan Waszczyński eds. (Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich, 1989), 343-456.

Gu, Michael, Plus, Token (PLUS) Scam - Anatomy of a Ponzi (2022), https://perma.cc/PT6K-HZ3V (access: 02.06.2024).

Gupta, Mudit [@Mudit_Gupta], Tweet, https://twitter.com/ Mudit__Gupta/status/1523306186761596929, (access: 24.07.2022).

Hazel, Luna Foundation Guard Has Acquired an Additional 37,863 Bitcoins Worth $1,5 Billion (2022), https://perma.cc/ YHZ2-XVTE (access: 02.06.2024).

Hughes, Sarah J., "Gatekeepers" Are Vital Participants in Anti- Money-Laundering Laws and Enforcement Regimes as Permission- less Blockchain-Based Transactions Pose Challenges to Current Means to "Follow the Money", George Mason University Legal Studies Research Paper 408 (2019), https://perma. cc/8WB9-CJRB (access: 02.06.2024).

Jung-a, Song, South Korea launches investigations into company behind luna crypto cash (2022), https://perma.cc/8UMDFQME (access: 02.06.2024).

Kereiakes, Evan, Kwon, Do, Di Maggio, Marco, Platias, Nicholas, Terra Money: Stability and Adoption (2019), https://perma.cc/ D3XA-ZXBJ (access: 02.06.2024).

Kozhan, Roman, Viswanath-Natraj, Ganesh, Decentralized Stablecoins and Collateral Risk. WBS Finance Group Research Paper (2021) https://ssrn.com/abstract=3866975 (access: 02.06.2024).

Kwon, Do [@stablekwon], Tweet (2022), https://twitter.com/stablekwon/ status/1523532474860539905 (access: 24.07.2024).

Malwa, S. (2022, April 20). Terra"s LUNA Surges 17% as UST Becomes Third Largest Stablecoin. Retrieved 2022.07.24 and

saved to https://perma.cc/Z7F2-Z89M. Malwa, Shaurya, 3AC confirms near $200 million loss from Luna collapse. The Terra-Luna situation caught us very much off guard (2022, June 17), https://perma.cc/KFV4-FR6V (access: 02.06.2024)

Malwa, Shaurya, Terra"s LUNA Has Dropped 99.7% in Under a Week. That"s Good for UST (2022, May 12), https://perma. cc/2KEF-KK4J (access 24.07.2022).

Martinez, Ali [@ali_charts], [Tweet] (2022), https://twitter.com/ ali_charts/status/1525816636774797312 (access: 02.06.2024).

Onchain Wizard [@OnChainWizard], Tweet (2022), https:// twitter.com/OnChainWizard/status/1524123935570382851 (access: 02.06.2024).

Oosterbaan, Edward, The Elon Effect: How Musk"s Tweets Move Crypto Markets (2021), https://perma.cc/84G2-B68J (access: 14.07.2022).

Reynolds, Sam, Luna Foundation Guard Lends $1.5B in BTC and UST for Stablecoin Peg (2022), https://perma.cc/XJZ2-XP2J (access: 02.06.2024).

Saengchote, Kanis, A DeFi Bank Run: Iron Finance, IRON Stablecoin, and the Fall of TITAN (2021), https://ssrn.com/ abstract=3888089 (access: 02.06.2024).

Titcomb, James, Rishi Sunak to legalise "stablecoins" despite cryptocurrency crash (2022), https://perma.cc/ZR2E-SCBL (access: 02.06.2024).

Zetzsche, Dirk A., Buckley, Ross P., Arner, Douglas W., Remaining regulatory challenges in digital finance and crypto-assets after MiCA, publication for the Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs (ECON), Policy Department for Economic, Scientific and Quality of Life Policies, European Parliament, (STUDY Requested by the ECON Committee: 2023), https:// perma.cc/F6B2-5A8B (access: 02.06.2024).

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2024 Forum Prawnicze

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.